Committee Meeting Minutes November 14th 2022

Meeting Minutes

Minutes of Hammers United Committee Meeting held on Monday 14th  November 2nd 2022. 

Present 

P Colborne(Chairman)

A Byrne,A McConnell(Joint Secretaries)

G Bernard,R Blane,A Payne,S Patel,D Procter,L Rogers,

The Chairman called the meeting to order at 6.00 pm sharp.

Apologies. 

D Holder, T Twohig.

  1. INDEPENDENT SUPPORTERS COMMITTEE.

(a).Costs of ISC website. 

Chair reported this would be £212.80 for a 3 year period split between all the member groups,seeking endorsement of Hammers United contribution which would be between £20 and £30. This was endorsed.

(b).Hammers United motions to the ISC. 

‘That H.U. believes that the ISC should urgently consider whether or not the Club is adhering to its obligations with regard to consulting both collectively (with the ISC as one entity) and individually (under Structured Dialogue).’    

Chair reported that he had tabled as instructed. Unfortunately it was the unanimous (apart from HU) ISC view that the club was indeed adhering to its obligations and the motion was not seconded.

This led to debate round the table with committee members expressing huge disappointment.- What consultation had there been over the lower West Stand wall?

‘That H.U. believes the ISC must urgently debate the issue of “Consultation” (between the Club and the ISC), define what “consultation” must involve, reach agreement on the non-negotiable means by which such consultation must be conducted (by both the Club and ISC) and urgently convene a meeting with the Club to present its (the ISC’s) recommendations.  

Chair reported that the ISC communications subcommittee had taken consultation on board and he had subsequently withdrawn the resolution, formally requesting that AB be adopted onto this sub committee. – Noted.

(c).Club’s proposed changes to communications process. 

Chair reminded the meeting that the ISC had rejected the club’s proposal. The ISC Interim Chair had drafted a counter proposal similar to the one put forward by the Club but withdrew it at the meeting. The ISC subcommittee on communications had written to the club suggesting they come back with another proposal.

(d). Election of ISC Chair and Vice Chair. 

Chair drew attention to ISC MOU and Supporters Representation Guide which clearly stated that elections should have taken place.The ISC was clearly in breach of its own MOU. He then read out a letter he had sent to the FSA calling for immediate elections. – This was endorsed.

Chair explained FSA reply that elections were in fact the responsibility of the ISC Interim Chair and that our ISC rep should raise with her. AM pointed out that she had been copied into correspondence but nevertheless had written accordingly. – This was endorsed.

Chair went on to report that the Interim Chair had now asked supporters groups to elect ISC reps. Nominations would then be taken for ISC Chair and Vice Chair. – Noted.

  1. FSA REPORT ON ISC

Chair drew attention to the report already circulated.

This led to debate round the table with RB tabling the motion, ‘Following the long awaited receipt of the FSA Report the HU Committee consider it right and proper that HU should be given the right to respond and that the response should be appended to that Report, given that it  lacks balance and is unsound.’ 

Motion was seconded by SP and carried unanimously.

There being no further business Chair closed the meeting at 7.15 pm thanking all for attending.