Minutes of Hammers United Committee meeting (on zoom) held on Monday December 4th 2023
Chair opened the meeting at 6.00pm sharp.
Present:
P Colborne (Chair)
A Byrne, S Cross (Joint Secretaries)
G Barnard, A Payne, D Procter, L Rogers
Apologies:
Received from A Baker, R Moran, S Patel, I Pinamonti-Hyde, T Twohig
Proposed Fan Advisory Board:
Chair reported that after 3 months or so the Club had finally come back to the ISC with a revised proposal.
The ISC were meeting on December 6th to consider, and tonight’s meeting was to mandate our ISC rep, Andy Payne, for feeding HU’s response into the ISC meeting accordingly.
Chair then drew attention to our last committee minutes:
1: Old School Hammers
A Payne gave an update:
There was still no procedure in place for a new group to be adopted onto the ISC. Old School Hammers had now issued a formal complaint to the Club, the ISC and the FSA.- Noted.
2: Minutes of ISC/Club meeting held on July 18th 2023
The Club had made several amendments and the minutes were not a true record.
A Payne had now drafted a replacement minute and forwarded to the ISC for endorsement and forwarding to the Club.
A Payne reported that there had been no further progress and minutes had still not been finalised.- Noted with concern.
3: Minutes of ISC meeting held on 1st August 2023
Chair of the ISC had omitted debate on Club Cash. Andy Payne had specifically requested this be minuted.- The ISC minutes are not a true record.
A Payne reported that the ISC Chair would be contacting him to arrange a meeting to discuss.
A Payne reported the ISC had not contacted him and there had been no progress.
A Payne went on to report that ISC meetings had now been held in both September and October and minutes had not yet been published.- Noted with concern.
This led to L Rogers expressing the opinion that ISC meetings should be recorded and that A Payne should formally move this at the start of the next ISC meeting.
This was then presented as a motion by L Rogers, seconded by A Byrne and carried unanimously.
A Payne will formally move this at the ISC meeting.
Chair pointed out that this was the agreed policy of the Supporters Trust so we could count on their support.
4: The following motion was moved by G Barnard
“That Hammers United cannot and will not betray the West Ham United fanbase and thus will only be part of an FAB where fans and independents decide on the members. The Club cannot choose who represents fans on the FAB.”
This was seconded by I Pinamonti-Hyde and carried unanimously.
To this end?the Chair and Joint Secretaries will seek a meeting with the FSA to discuss the proposed FAB and report back to this committee at a special meeting to be convened as soon as possible. The sole agenda item being how best Hammers United continue to serve the West Ham United fanbase.
A Payne reported that he had met the FSA and had requested they meet the ISC. This had been achieved and the FSA had confirmed their position to the ISC that any proposed FAB must be independent of the Club.
This was noted, with thanks to A Payne for his efforts on behalf of our members and the West Ham fanbase.
A Payne then reported the Club’s latest proposals for the FAB
A Payne pointed out that the Club proposed to morph the existing ISC into the FAB.
He went on to outline the club’s proposals and discussions to date with the ISC.
This led to full and frank debate leading to the following 3 motions being tabled:
1: “That HU reaffirm its position as laid down in its previous motion to the ISC – That the ISC/FAB is to be independent of West Ham United Football Club and accordingly will produce and adopt a written constitution to ensure that it is democratic, accountable, transparent and independent.”
Moved – P Colborne, seconded – G Barnard
Carried unanimously.
A Payne would inform the ISC of HU’s position.
2: “That elections must be held as laid down in the ISC’s own terms .”
Moved L Rogers,seconded D Procter
Carried unanimously.
A Payne would inform the ISC of HU’s position.
3: “That stringent criteria must be met by any group aspiring to join the FAB, ensuring they are democratic, accountable ,transparent and independent of the Club.”
Moved D Procter, seconded A Byrne
Carried unanimously.
A Payne would inform the ISC of HU’s position.
There being no further business Chair closed the meeting at 6.30 pm thanking all for attending.



