Minutes of Hammers United Committee Meeting held on Monday October 11th.
Present:
P Colborne(Chairman). A Byrne, A McConnell (Joint Secretaries).
Committee members: G Bernard, R Blane, S Patel, A Payne, D Procter, L Rogers, V Ryan, T Twohig.
The Chairman called the meeting to order at 5.30 pm and gave apologies received from D Holder.
Independent Supporters Committee
The Chairman gave a full report on the Independent Supporters Committee.
The Club was not complying with the MOU. It was not engaging meaningfully with the Supporters groups.
Some members of the ISC had ignored process and met the Club behind the ISC’s back.**
It was apparent that some members of the ISC did not canvass or report back to members and were infact answerable to no-one.
Both Joint Secretaries and Roy Blane had served on ISC committees and reported back accordingly.
Roy Blane argued passionately that the ISC had failed dismally and should be disbanded.
A Mconnell added that the ISC had agreed that a meeting be set up between the club, 3 reps from the ISC and the FSA to discuss consultation.
ISC Chair had met Karren Brady and agreed a joint statement unilaterally!!**
This led to full and frank debate round the table. The committee were very disappointed that the club were in effect using the ISC as a box ticking exercise.
They were amazed to hear that ISC members, including the present Chair had met the club behind the ISC’s back and that the Chair had done this before.
They were aghast to hear that the ISC was not a democratic constraint.
This led to Lee Rogers moving:
1.That the Joint Secretaries write to the ISC reporting that Hammers United would be conducting a full review into the terms agreed in the MOU as we believe that some factors have fallen into disrepute.
2.That the Joint Secretaries write to the Chair seeking clarification on their meeting with Karren Brady.
S Patel moved an amendment whereby the results of the review be circulated to membership and the West Ham fanbase as a whole. This was seconded by P Colborne.
The amended motion was carried 10 votes to 1.
Protest
The Chairman gave a full report which was noted.
Other Business
The Chairman reported on pink cancer shirt being stolen from a West Ham Supporter at the last home game, and the distress experienced by this supporter.
L Rogers moved Hammers United buy her a new replacement shirt, seconded G Bernard and carried unanimously.
There being no further business the Chairman closed the meeting at 6.50 pm thanking all for attending.
**On 31 August 2021, the full ISC took a collective decision to meet the club to discuss the process of consultation. The ISC specifically identified Karren Brady as one member of club staff whom they would like invited to be part of that discussion.
On October 11 Hammers United held a full committee meeting (minutes above). At this committee meeting, correspondence HU had received on 10 October was discussed. That correspondence implied that the planned meeting on consultation had been held between Sue Watson and Karren Brady only. The phraseology in a joint statement, agreed at the meeting on consultation, led HU to believe that this was the case.
HU discussed the information they held at the time, in their committee meeting on 11 October and included it in the minutes of that meeting (above).
We are now aware that the meeting around consultation took place on 7 October and was attended by Karren Brady, Tara Warren, Nicola Keye, Jake Heath, Sue Watson, Cathy Bayford and Steve Applebee.



