Heading towards the new Premier League season, there feels a different mood amongst supporters. Fanbases are such an eclectic mix of generations, communities, faiths etc that it is impossible to presume one unified perspective but there certainly appears a more collective and assertive approach towards clubs, especially over ticket prices. Protests this season will be more cross-club, not only individual.
Take West Ham United. Their fans are in dispute with the club over changes to ticket prices and concessionary arrangements, whether cost or relocation in the London Stadium. Their response has been strengthened by more collective action led by Andy Payne, chair of the West Ham Independent Supporters Committee. The ISC represents seven leading West Ham fans’ groups with 25,000 members and will become the Fan Advisory Board.
“We’ve united all the fan groups here now, it’s taken a while!” Payne smiles. “We were quite good at being each others’ throats because everyone’s got an opinion!” He’s a passionate West Ham fan, genial individual and successful video-game businessman who I met travelling round Germany this summer. He’s followed England since 1982. On returning from the Berlin final, Payne attended the Football Supporters’ Association AGM at Wembley, tapping into the experiences and expertise of other fans’ groups.
“What’s been heartening is sitting down talking to Spirit of Shankly (of Liverpool) and Everton Fan Advisory Board,” Payne says. “Ian Byrne (MP) is on the Spirit of Shankly committee. Ian and Dave Kelly (chair) of Everton Fan Advisory Board are the gold standard of fan mobilisation. They have a union mentality running through them. I’m learning from Ian and Dave.
“It’s also been heartening talking to fans from Forest, Wolves and Spurs. Spurs and West Ham fans talking like this! Chelsea!” Divided by post-codes and decades of tribalism but now united by common concerns. “All of these fan groups are facing up to different degrees of pricing attack. This isn’t good for the game and is unnecessary. Football has a spending problem, not a revenue problem. To lump it on to fans is unnecessary.”
To consider the club’s viewpoint, West Ham talk of their pride in continuing “to offer our supporters some of the cheapest season ticket prices in London and the Premier League, and that they are responding to Profit & Sustainability Rules, the lingering cost of lockdown and games behind closed doors and also the loss of revenue of now not being in Europe. They could also point to the waiting list and fans’ desire for new players. “If West Ham were to say to us, ‘we need to get X amount more revenue a year, you lot stop shouting, tell us how we can do it, give us some ideas?’ We’d do that,” Payne replies.
Like? “We should have a commercial (naming rights) sponsor for the London Stadium.” It’s complicated because West Ham only lease the stadium, and negotiations for naming rights are through the London Legacy Development Corporation which would take its share. Allianz and the ticketing firm Stage Front have been linked as potential sponsors.
If that eventually comes down to money, you definitely cannot put a price on goodwill. Payne made that point when talking to a senior member of the West Ham hierarchy at the London Stadium recently. “There are 62,000 out there,” Payne told them, gesturing to the stands. “Take the away fans out of it, and what you want is the best part of 55,000 to 58,000 screaming their heads off wanting to support their team all the time and then they’ll buy your popcorn, your burgers, your beer and your merchandise and they will love the place.
“The boys who represent us on a Saturday should be feeling as much positivity as possible. I beg you to reconsider what you’re doing with these concessions. Right now, with the fanbase, we don’t need petrol on this fire. Don’t lose the goodwill of fans. By all means make the club global (with tourists) but we will be here against Blackpool on a Wednesday night if we get relegated.” Will the tourists?
The situation is helped by the arrival from Chelsea of Cat Smith as head of supporter services and fan engagement. “She’s absolutely brilliant, a breath of fresh air,” Payne says. Smith is also a third-generation West Ham fan so will be aware of the concerns.
Fans, of course, are a captive audience. Clubs know – or certainly believe – that their fans can’t take their allegiance elsewhere. “It’s not like buying a new iPhone or washing powder,” Payne acknowledges. “I can’t go and ‘buy’ Charlton. You certainly can’t go and buy Millwall or Tottenham as a West Ham fan. We ‘buy’ West Ham.”
Payne is determined to keep dialogue with the club respectful. “We’re going to be professional, honourable and polite but we are also going to be firm,” he says. “We want to show the world that we will be positive. We love West Ham. If West Ham would just go ‘freeze (the changes), hold, let’s go into discussions’.”
Communication is key. So is working together. All parties want what’s best for the club. West Ham are best when United. West Ham’s vice-chairman, Karren Brady, didn’t build a hugely successful business career on ignoring the views of “customers”. On July 14, West Ham responded to fans’ criticism by stating it “would like to reassure our loyal season ticket holders that the Club remains absolutely committed to our policy of providing affordable family football at London Stadium.
“Our concessionary discount policies have been designed to ensure that our longest-standing season ticket holders are rewarded for their loyalty and commitment, and that our young supporters – the future of the Club – and their families are always provided with an affordable matchday experience.” The club added that it had consulted with fans groups and “committed to delivering” a range of initiatives “for the benefit of new and relocating Season Ticket Holders”.
Payne calls for more consultation. The imminent establishment of the Fan Advisory Board, at the very least, will make the process of communication easier. But Payne adds, “There’s no vision, there’s no German Uli Hoeness (approach of) ‘why would Bayern Munich want to put the bill on the door of the working-class fan who we want here forever’. What’s clear is that this is happening everywhere: Forest, Wolves, Spurs, Liverpool, Everton, Manchester City. Despite success on the field for some of those clubs, the fans’ representatives are feeling ‘hang on a minute we’ve got concessions of young and old that are under attack’.”
The FSA provides a sounding board, a meeting place, a platform for sharing ideas and support structure. “We work very closely with the FSA,” Payne continues. “Through the FSA, fan groups are now in cross-club discussions. We will build databases, look at prices, start doing some data analysis, things that owners probably don’t expect us to do we will do. We will be peacefully protesting.
“We do believe there will be next season, not just a couple of games, there will be a building of coordinated cross-club protests, all peaceful, all within the law, nothing to spoil other fans’ views of the game, creative stuff. Liverpool and Everton fans are good at looking at sponsors. So we are boycotting the Betway friendly against Celta Vigo (at the London Stadium on August 10). We just said to fans instead of paying your money (for tickets) to donate the money to Irons Supporting Foodbanks. We’re going to push that like crazy. Exactly like they do in Liverpool and in Manchester.”
The campaign comes in many forms. Hammers United, one of the ISC’s constituent parts, lobby five East London and Essex MPs to take up their case with the club. “Stephen Timms, East Ham MP, who I know, has written to Brady,” Payne adds. The ISC will be leafletting fans about ticketing issues at the opening home game of the season, against Aston Villa on August 17.
Club legends like Tony Cottee and Frank McAvennie have urged fans to sign Hammers United’s petition calling on the club to “scrap the season ticket price increases; commit to never increasing the price of a season ticket above the prevailing CPI; scrap the new concession terms and conditions; and commit to never changing concession terms and conditions again”. As of 9am today, 13,413 people had signed the petition, including 562 in the past 24 hours which at the very least signals the club’s July 14 message is not getting through.
Other methods of protests are being considered. “Tennis balls (thrown on to pitch) in Germany appeals to us,” Payne adds, “and black balloons.” Black balloons? “Yes, like black bubbles. Let them float around, ‘I’m forever blowing black bubbles’, black, (signifying) the death of the club.” Bit extreme? “We don’t want the conflict,” Payne adds. But it is a conflict, one that needs addressing by clubs across the Premier League. Why lose supporter goodwill for the price of an agent’s fee?
The original article can be found here >>



