Minutes of Hammers United Committee meeting (on Zoom) held on Tuesday January 23rd 2024
Chair opened the meeting at 6.30pm sharp.
Present:
P Colborne (Chair)
A Byrne, S Cross (Joint Secretaries)
G Barnard, A Payne, D Procter, S Patel, I Pinamonti-Hyde, L Rogers.
Apologies:
Received from A Baker, R Moran, T Twohig.
Hammers United Motions:
Chair updated as follows:
1: “That HU reaffirm its position as laid down in its previous motion to the ISC – That the ISC/FAB is to be independent of West Ham United Football Club and accordingly will produce and adopt a written constitution to ensure that it is democratic, accountable, transparent and independent.”
Chair reported that this was now the ISC’s position and thanked the FSA for their assistance.
2: “That elections must be held as laid down in the ISC’s own terms.”
Chair reported that this had been seconded by the Supporters Club but had been defeated by 8 votes to 2. This led to debate round the table and concern that the ISC’s credibility would be hugely compromised. Lee Rogers expressed his concerns and disappointment and asked that this be recorded in the minutes. He hoped HU could urge the ISC to reconsider.
A.Payne reported that he had explained the background to the ISC, asking them to revisit their decision and that the decision had been reaffirmed.
3: “That stringent criteria must be met by any group aspiring to join the FAB, ensuring they are democratic, accountable, transparent and independent of the Club.”
Chair reported that the FSA had drafted joining criteria and invited input and edit from the ISC. Andy Payne had provided HU’s input in line with our motion.
ISC/FAB:
Chair invited Andy Payne to give a progress report.
1: ISC Chair & Vice Chair:
A Payne reported that both the Chair and Vice Chair of the ISC had resigned with immediate effect. The ISC had appointed A Payne on the 16th of January as Interim Chair to oversee the FAB negotiation with the club. – Noted, all present congratulated Andy, wishing him every success in what will be a monumental task ahead.
Andy then reported that the Away Season ticket rep had also resigned with immediate effect 22nd January 2023.-This was also noted.
2: Proposed Fan Advisory Board:
A Payne reported that the ISC had been progressing their response to the Club and that he had made considerable input in line with HU policy. The ISC would be meeting to finalise its response and would be meeting the club very soon. That date was still under review. He went on to report that the Bondholders had informed the ISC that they would not be joining the proposed FAB.- Noted.
3: Minutes of ISC/Club meeting held on July 18th 2023:
A Payne reported that as ISC Interim Chair he had taken steps to resolve and that these had now been published with a statement from the ISC covering differences between the Club’s version of the minutes, which will be published and the ISC’s version. The way in which minutes will be recorded for future meetings will need to change and this is to be agreed with the Club.
4: Minutes of August, September and October meetings:
A Payne reported that as ISC Interim Chair he had taken steps to resolve and that these would now been published.
5: ISC Subcommittees:
Chair reminded the committee that there had been ISC subcommittees set up to deal with core work, principally on ticketing, communications, match day experience, and history and heritage. Unfortunately none of these subcommittees had met for months and Andy Payne had asked the ISC to consider agreeing the outstanding fan related issues and then progressing these with the Club. A Payne had offered to draft a report for the ISC and asked that HU endorse his recommendation that we do so ASAP.
Chair thanked Andy P for his report and endorsed accordingly.
At this point Lee Rogers asked for a progress report on HU’s motion that ISC meetings be recorded. Andy P reported differing views among the ISC members but everyone agreed that we need a more efficient and accurate way of taking minutes.
HU Chair (Paul C) reported that he had attempted to move for debate and a vote at the ISC meeting he had attended due to AP being away on business. The ISC Chair (Steve Applebee) had not allowed this due to time constraints. Paul C explained that he had challenged the ISC Chair but had been unsuccessful.
Lee Rogers asked if we could take steps to ensure this important issue was debated. A Payne agreed to take this up with the ISC.
Hammers United Next Steps:
Chair made a recommendation brought forward for discussion by himself and the Joint Secretaries. This was endorsed unanimously, the consensus being there was cause for optimism on what we might achieve on behalf of our members and the wider fanbase.
Chair went on to report that we would start work straight away and get out as soon as possible.
There being no further business Chair closed the meeting at 7.29 pm. thanking all for attending.



