Hammers United Committee Meeting 3/1/23

Meeting Minutes

Minutes of Hammers United Committee Meeting held on Monday January 2nd 2023. 

Present 

P Colborne (Chair)

A Byrne, A McConnell (Joint Secretaries)

G Bernard, D Holder, A Payne, D Procter ,L Rogers, T Twohig.

Apologies. 

Received from S Patel and V Ryan.

The Chair called the meeting to order at 5.00 pm sharp. There was one item on the agenda, namely European Conference League home match ticket prices.

Chair read out the club’s ticket price announcement.

Chair gave background and then asked Andy Payne HU ISC member for a full report.

 

Andy reported that these ticket prices were initially announced to the ISC’s Ticketing Subcommittee (TSC) at a meeting which took place on 22 December. The meeting was called  with less than 24 hours notice by the club, nevertheless the meeting went ahead. We do not know exactly who was present as we have not yet received minutes. Hammers United were not present at this meeting.

 

Andy reported his understanding that the consensus among those ISC members in attendance was that the prices were reasonable, the deadline for season ticket holders to apply had been extended and there was a discount for disabled supporters. We understand that no challenge to the pricing was forthcoming at the meeting . This consensus was reached by those members of the TSC who were present at the meeting.

The Chair of the TSC did not report back to the full ISC and it wasn’t until 29 December during an ISC WhatsApp exchange that it became apparent to the full committee that the meeting had actually taken place. Therefore the ISC had not been given the opportunity to meet, consider and reach a consensus of opinion which could be put to the club. The Supporters Club and Hammers United reps immediately raised their concerns but by this time the Club had already published the ticket prices (effectively endorsed by the TSC) to the fan base.

 

Chair thanked Andy for his report.

 

Chair then reported that he had contacted a majority of HU Committee members and that Hammers United Committee believed that the prices are too high. It also believed it is unreasonable that season ticket holders have to pay for their seats by Feb 7th with the draw not even made until Feb 24. Furthermore it was alarmed that due process had not been followed.

 

Chair then sought formal endorsement of this position. This was moved by AM, seconded LR and carried unanimously. 

 

The Chair went on to report that he had emailed Andy Payne the morning after receiving his report and read out the email in full:

Hi Andy, 

  

Thanks for your update on Conference League ticketing received last evening. We have consulted with members of our committee and unfortunately we cannot accept your report.  

 

The ISC ticketing sub committee should have reported back to the full ISC immediately for them to consider, debate and agree a position on this. Have you received the sub committee minutes yet?  

 

We obviously do not have the time to canvas our full membership. However our committee are all match going fans and are unanimous in their view that prices are too high. We have a duty to represent our members and get the best possible deal for them and indeed all West Ham supporters.I believe that, as it stands, we have fallen short.  

 

Could you please write to the full ISC moving that the ISC  ask the club to revisit these prices as the ISC believe they are excessive. This to be voted on by the ISC as laid down in  section 2.6.5. of the MOU whereby ALL ISC members vote and all votes are recorded. Ideally Andy this would be done at a special ISC meeting but due to time constraints we accept the vote may have to be taken by email.  

 

Thanks for your help. As requested we will respect confidentiality until the club releases prices.  

 

Speak soon.  

Paul. 

 

Chair then reported that Andy had subsequently immediately emailed all ISC members and read out Andy’s email in full:

 

Please see below from the chair of Hammers United, Paul Colborne, on behalf of Hammers United. 

 

Therefore I would like to move the motion that these prices are too high and the club should revisit them. Can we vote on this via email please, unless we are able to have an ISC meeting today, which I know will not be convenient to all. 

 

Paul knows the club have announced the ticketing prices yesterday now, just for the record.  Also if we can get a copy of the minutes, that would also be much appreciated. 

 

Kind regards, 

Andy 

 

Chair sought endorsement of his and AP’s actions. This was moved by LR, seconded by AB and carried unanimously.

 

Chair concluded by reporting that it was now 3 days since Andy’s email was sent to ISC and Andy had confirmed to him that not one reply had been received. Nevertheless he still hoped that the ISC would support our motion and challenge the club accordingly.

 

This led to full and frank debate round the table

 

L.R. suggested this committee write to the FSA pointing out that once again the ISC had let down West Hams supporters by not following due process and that this cannot continue. Chair pointed out that HU had complained to the FSA before and their position was that they had no jurisdiction over the ISC.

 

A.M. sought clarification on who the ISC were answerable to, surely there must be some accountability and control. Chair reported that his understanding was that there was no accountability and no control. The ISC were supposed to adhere to a laid down MOU but were often in breach. He had pointed out to both the Interim Chair and FSA on several occasions that the West Ham United fan base would ultimately be the ISC’s  judge and jury.

 

A.B. then moved that should replies not be received from the ISC by midday on January 4th A.P. should write to the ISC for the second and final time as follows:

 

Hammers United requests an Emergency ISC meeting to consider our position that  European Conference Ticketing prices are too high and that payment deadline is unacceptable. 

 

This was seconded by T.T. and carried unanimously.

 

The Committee then debated how best the ISC should go forward to ensure West Ham supporters were better represented in future.

 

Suggestions were made round the table leading to AM moving: that  

A.P. as HU rep raise concerns at the next ISC meeting and formally ask for a vote of confidence in the ISC subcommittee on ticketing. This to be a named vote under 2.6.5 of  Standing Orders. 

 

This was seconded by AP and carried unanimously.

 

GB then moved: that this committee seek the views of our membership on prices and deadlines. 

 

This was seconded by D.H. and carried unanimously.

 

There being no further business Chair closed the meeting at 6.00 pm thanking all for attending.