Club Cash

Club Cash Grab

Hammers United wrote to the club today as follows.

Hi [redcated]

Hope all is well,

Further to my previous email to you (see below), to which there has been no reply, I want to bring you up to speed with Hammers United’s ongoing investigations into the Club Cash scheme at West Ham, which we have broadened to include similar schemes at other clubs.

Having canvassed the opinions of Premier League supporters’ groups the consensus (exactly the same as it is at West Ham) is that refunds for season tickets that have been “resold” by a club on a game by game basis should be made in real cash as opposed to any form of “credit” such as the Club Cash scheme at West Ham.

Several clubs already offer real cash refunds as standard while others give their fans the option for real cash or a “credit” depending on their individual preference. We believe the latter would be a fair compromise and welcome the Club’s thoughts on this.

The issue of the “use it or lose it” deadline is universally opposed (again, see my previous email below). The terms and conditions may be clear on this point but the feeling among fans is that this is unethical and unacceptable. Last week Hammers United met with Trading Standards at Newham Town Hall to discuss the Club Cash scheme and you will note I have copied Trading Standards into this letter. Our discussions are ongoing .

With regard to the value of a refund, we have found that most other clubs use a simple calculation – the cost of the season ticket divided by the number of eligible games. Were that to be the case at West Ham, a season ticket holder with a ticket costing £650 “resold” by the club would receive £34.21 for each game: £650/19.

Unfortunately there is confusion amongst season ticket holders at West Ham and there seems to be nothing in the terms and conditions (for either the season ticket itself or the Club Cash scheme) which explains clearly how a “refund” is calculated. We are frequently contacted by our members claiming that Club Cash “refunds” are less than expected and that transparency is urgently required.This needs to be addressed in the terms and conditions.

Furthermore, we receive repeated requests for Club Cash scheme “credits” to be extended to include the purchase of home cup match tickets for both domestic and European fixtures. At a time when around 35000 West Ham fans will still be recovering from wonderful but expensive trips to Prague followed by between a 4-8% increase in the cost of a season ticket, we think this a reasonable request, especially for the group stages of the Europa League where we don’t always sell out. The closer we are to 60k fans roaring the team on, the better!

I now refer you to the content of our email dated May 30th:

We have received complaints from members concerned that they are going to lose their club cash balances.

Some members have reported to us that the club have imposed a ‘use it or lose it’ deadline of July 31st. It is the belief of the Hammers United committee that to enforce an arbitrary deadline by which fans MUST spend their Club Cash WITH THE CLUB is both immoral and unethical, despite what is written into the terms and conditions.

We simply cannot see any reason why there needs to be an arbitrary deadline, especially as the current rate of inflation diminishes the value of Club Cash, thus increasing the Club’s margins when Club Cash is used in the only way it can be used: on purchases with THE CLUB.

I would be grateful if you could confirm the club’s position on this, enabling us to report back to our 19400 members.

I do hope the Club will now address this as a matter of urgency as the deadline is fast approaching.

I also hope the Club will take on board the comments above and reconsider how the Club Cash scheme works in its entirety.

Thanking you for your assistance and hoping that between us we can improve the Club Cash scheme for West Ham supporters.

Kindest regards.

Paul