Hammers United / FAB Progress Report
Prepared by Andy Payne, Joint Secretary of Hammers United and Co-Chair of the Fan Advisory Board
16 May 2026
Purpose of this Report
This report is intended to provide Hammers United members and West Ham United supporters with a clear, evidence-based summary of the work undertaken through the Fan Advisory Board (FAB), the outcomes achieved, the areas where progress has been forced through supporter pressure, and the significant barriers that remain within the Club’s current executive culture and governance structures.
1. Context
The FAB was established under the Premier League’s Fan Engagement Standard with the stated intention of improving supporter dialogue and accountability. It followed on from the Independent Supporter Committee (ISC) which Hammers United were a founder. However, from the very outset, supporter representatives have faced defensive communication, delayed and non-responses, limited transparency and resistance from so called senior executive leaders at the Club to meaningful structural reform.
Despite this, supporter representatives on the FAB, which is made up of 13 supporter groups and chaired by myself have continued to press the Club using evidence, supporter consultation, financial analysis, benchmarking against peer clubs and sustained public pressure.
2. Key Progress and Achievements
The FAB has achieved several important outcomes despite operating in an environment where many decisions remain tightly controlled by senior executives and ownership.
• Season Ticket Price Freeze
Following sustained campaigning aligned with the national #StopExploitingLoyalty campaign, the FAB successfully argued for a season ticket price freeze should the Club remain in the Premier League. Sadly, the Club decided not to announce this before the Arsenal game. This was achieved through detailed benchmarking against other clubs, supporter surveys and repeated escalation of affordability concerns. We expect a real reduction in season ticket pricing for the Championship.
• Concessions Campaign Pressure
The FAB placed the removal of supporter concessions firmly onto the national football agenda. Supporter pressure exposed the social impact of removing long-standing concessions for younger supporters, pensioners and disabled fans.
• Ticketing Accountability
The FAB has consistently challenged the Club on pricing, match categorisation, ticket exchange policies and the continued insistence that season ticket holders will only be refunded for tickets sold on the Club’s Ticket Exchange via the absurd, unfair and morally wrong Club Cash system. We are told that Club Cash is ‘the brainchild of the Chairman’. As we look forward to the regime change that our Club desperately needs, we feel sure that Club Cash can be abolished. The Club has been forced to repeatedly revisit and justify its ticketing strategy under scrutiny and rightly so.
• Attendance Transparency
Through the use of FOI data and supporter analysis also provided by Hammers United, the FAB challenged the narrative around ‘sold out’ attendances and highlighted the growing disconnect between tickets sold and actual supporters entering the stadium. With an average of 10,000 supporters per game in the stadium less than reported, we will continue to press the Club for honesty.
• Fan Safety and Home End Integrity
The FAB has repeatedly raised concerns regarding away supporters entering home areas, particularly through hospitality and third-party ticketing channels, such as P1 Travel. This has resulted in increased operational checks and greater recognition of the issue by the Club. But there is still so much work for the Club to do as with so many other aspects that we always discuss.
• Governance and Financial Scrutiny
The FAB issue a Vote of No Confidence in the board back in August 2025. This forced unprecedented scrutiny onto the Club’s governance structures, decision-making processes and PSR-related narratives. Requests for organisational charts, risk registers, budgeting assumptions and strategic plans have fundamentally shifted the tone of supporter engagement from passive consultation to active accountability. It was clear that under the ‘leadership’ of Brady, the strategy was clear, ‘stay in the Premier League and all is well’. We warned the Club that this complete lack of strategy would mean we would face relegation. Our warnings were laughed at by senior leaders at the Club. None of us take any pleasure at being proved right.
• Supporter Conduct and Due Process
The FAB has challenged the Club over supporter sanctions, banning processes and lack of transparency. Significant changes to the Supporter Conduct Charter were slipped through unannounced at the start of the season. The FAB caught the Club out, again. This has opened discussions around restorative justice models, evidence disclosure and supporter rights. These rights have to restored, it really is non-negotiable.
3. Challenges and Executive Resistance
While progress has undoubtedly been made, it is equally important to be honest about the obstacles that remain.
Too often, supporter engagement at West Ham United still feels reactive rather than collaborative. Important questions are frequently delayed, reframed or answered indirectly. Key information requested by supporter representatives is often withheld, heavily controlled, or just ignored, hoping it will go away.
The FAB has seen two Nominated Board Level Officials (NBLOs) pass through. Tara Warren left in the Autumn and then Karren Brady left in April. Neither added anything positive for any West Ham United supporters, indeed both will be viewed as toxic, deluded and complacent. These people worked for the majority shareholder, David Sullivan. Never forget that.
There remains a significant gap between the Club’s public messaging around ‘Fans First’ and the lived experience of many supporters.
Examples include:
• Failure to fully restore concessions.
• Ongoing concerns around ticket affordability.
• Lack of meaningful transparency over strategic direction.
• Resistance to publishing actual attendance figures.
• Continued supporter frustration regarding communication standards.
• A tendency to treat supporter engagement as reputation management rather than partnership.
The FAB has often had to force issues into the open through persistence, evidence and public accountability rather than through genuine executive cooperation.
4. Why the FAB Matters
Without the FAB and organised supporter pressure, many of these issues would simply not have been addressed at all.
The FAB has become an essential mechanism for:
• Holding the Club accountable.
• Preserving football as a community institution.
• Defending supporter culture and traditions.
• Challenging poor governance and weak communication.
• Protecting accessibility and affordability.
• Ensuring supporter concerns are formally recorded and evidenced.
The progress achieved so far demonstrates what can happen when supporters organise professionally, work collaboratively across fan groups and refuse to accept superficial engagement.
5. The Work Still Ahead
But so much more remains to be done.
Key priorities moving forward include:
• The Club needs new majority ownership. David Sullivan’s reign is now at an end.
• Securing long-term protection for concessions.
• Reforming ticket exchange policies.
• Delivering greater financial transparency.
• Improving governance accountability.
• Establishing clearer supporter rights and protections.
• Changing key aspects of the stadium so that the atmosphere improves and establishing identity of home areas.
• Ensuring the Fan Engagement Standard becomes meaningful rather than a compliance exercise.
• To make West Ham United Again.
Supporters have shown that organised, evidence-led campaigning can deliver results. The challenge now is ensuring those gains are protected and expanded.
6. Conclusion
The FAB has not solved every issue at West Ham United. No supporter representative should pretend otherwise.
However, meaningful progress has been achieved in difficult circumstances and despite resistance from the Club. The Club’s executive leadership has been challenged more robustly than at any point since the move to the London Stadium, and supporter concerns can no longer simply be ignored or dismissed.
The work undertaken by supporter representatives, Hammers United included has helped shift the balance of power towards greater scrutiny, greater transparency and greater accountability.
This report is therefore not a declaration of victory. It is evidence that organised supporters, working together, can still influence the direction of their football club — even when cooperation from the executive level is inconsistent or reluctant.
Prepared for Hammers United members and supporters.
COYI.



