Minutes of the (virtual by Zoom) Hammers United Annual General Meeting held on Tuesday May 15th 2024..
Present
P Colborne (Chair)
S Cross (Joint Secretary)
Committee members:-
A Payne, R Moran, I Pinamonti-Hyde, D Procter, L Rogers
Members:-
M Adie, P Anderson, J Barnes ,A Byrne, T Colborne, M Field, T Fischer, M Gunn, M Hammar, D Houghton, M Johal, A McConnell, L Pearce, P Prideaux, P Turner, M Vanderpump, C Wells .
The Chair called the meeting to order at 7.00 pm thanking all for attending. He proposed that the meeting should be recorded and there were no objections.
Apologies.
Received from J Glover, S Law, G Marling, M Telling.
Annual Report.
Chair drew attention to the Annual Report, already circulated. Report approved.
Joint Secretaries Report.
Chair drew attention to Joint Secretaries report, already circulated. Report approved.
Treasurers report
Chair drew attention to Treasurers report, already circulated. Report approved.
Election of Hammers United Committee.
Chair confirmed that 12 positions were available. He then reminded the meeting that 12 nominations had been received and formally seconded and election addresses circulated.
Chair read out the names of nominees as follows:-
A Baker, moved P Colborne, seconded A Payne.
P Colborne, moved T Colborne, seconded A McConnell.
S Cross, moved P Colborne, seconded A Payne.
R Moran, moved L Rogers, seconded P Colborne.
S Patel, moved M Telling, seconded G Penfold.
A Payne, moved A Byrne, seconded L Rogers.
L Pearce, moved A McConnell, seconded L Rogers.
I Pinamonti-Hyde, moved P Colborne, seconded A McConnell.
D Procter, moved A Payne, seconded G Penfold.
L Rogers, moved D Rogers, seconded P Colborne.
P Turner, moved P Colborne, seconded A Payne.
C Wells, moved P Stringfellow, seconded M Field.
Each were ratified individually by an affirmative vote.
Election of Chair.
Chair asked for nominations leading to L Rogers nominating P Colborne. Nomination was seconded by C Wells. There being no further nominations P Colborne was re-elected.
Election of Joint Secretaries.
Chair called for nominations leading to nominations as follows:-
A McConnell nominated A Payne. Nomination was seconded by P Colborne.
L Rogers nominated S Cross. Nomination was seconded by a C Wells.
There being no further nominations A Payne was elected and S Cross re-elected.
Election of representative on Independent Supporters Committee.
Chair called for nominations, drawing attention to A Payne’s sterling work to date on this committee and proposing he be re-elected, nominating accordingly. Nomination was seconded by L Rogers. There being no further nominations A Payne wasre-elected.
Fitting tribute to the late John Lyall.
Chair drew attention to H.U. achieving a plaque honouring John at Ilford High School.
He went on to report on meetings with Murray Lyall and that a number of ideas had been discussed leading to a strategy being agreed. One initiative would be to rename the walk route from Endeavour Square to the Stadium (over Bridge 1) John Lyall way. Hammers United had approached LLDC accordingly. We would be reporting back to members soon. Noted.
Disability Football.
Chair reported that aided by Colin Wells he was drawing up a proposal to put to the club. We would be in a position to report back to members very soon.-Noted.
Survey.
Chair reminded the meeting of the success of Hammers United’s previous survey and the Committee’s view that another survey should go out as soon as possible .This would give Hammers United a mandate for presenting a ‘shopping list’ to the new Fan Advisory Board. The committee proposed getting the survey out in June. Endorsed.
Proposed Season Ticket prices and changes to concessions.
Andy Payne and Chair gave a full report.
Prices had risen by 8% last season and an average of 7% the season before. The ISC had proactively written to the club on March 11th calling for prices to be held at 2023/2024 rate.
Yet again there had been no meaningful engagement with the ISC and the club had announced rises of between 6 and 14%.They also proposed significant changes to concessions whereby new season tickets at concession rate could only be in bands 5 or 6.
The ISC had called upon the club to reconsider but the club had confirmed that they would be sticking to their plans.
Chair and Andy Payne had met football finance expert Kieran Maguire to discuss the club’s rationale against a background of them not having the stadium costs incurred by other clubs.
Andy had met with Chairs of Premier League Fan Advisory Boards and both Andy and Paul had attended FSA Premier League meetings. There was a clear appetite for co-ordinated campaigns and protest across Premier League Supporters Groups.
Mike Field had also attended FSA meeting and supported this view.
Report was noted.
Independent supporters Committee/Fan Advisory Board.
Andy Payne and Chair gave a full report.
The Premier League had announced its fan engagement standard in June 2023 whereby Fan Advisory Boards will operate to deliver meaningful fan engagement and representation. Andy reported that the ISC was now professional and completely united in it’s efforts under Andy’s leadership and was working hard to secure the best possible terms for the new FAB. The final draft was expected from the club in the next few days.
The Football Supporters’ Association (FSA), Independent Football Regulator (IFR) and Premier League (PL) would all be monitoring progress so it was hoped the club would engage meaningfully with the fan groups for the benefit of West Ham fans.
Andy reported that the PL had clarified at the FAB chairs meeting held in March that the FABs could be independent of the clubs under the PL’s Fan Engagement Standard (FES) guidance and framework. He reported that the club had consistently refused to accept the independence of the FAB when the ISC had challenged this on multiple occasions. He also reported that some other club FABs have true independence from their clubs, Everton for example, and some were simply not independent of their clubs – Arsenal, Spurs and Chelsea for example. One club, Fulham had issued terms to fan groups with no negotiation at all. Consequently, for West Ham, those fan groups who wanted to apply to become part of the FAB would have to accept the club’s interpretation of the PL guidance. This approach had not been agreed by the ISC but had to be accepted. In response to this the ISC had voted unanimously to continue and become a platform for all West Ham fan groups to meet and agree policy completely independently of the club. The ISC had also agreed to expand its membership once the FAB had been established.
Andy also reported that the club and the ISC had not been able to agree the minutes from meetings with the club in January and in April. This is not the first time that agreement on the minutes was not agreed between the ISC and club. The ISC will put a statement out to explain why these minutes remain unpublished and why they are unhappy with the current minutes that the club say are a closed matter and will not be discussed again. The club also claim that they had told the ISC that it would no longer be recognised by the club during the meeting in January. This was clearly not agreed with the ISC at the time, nor since, as the ISC had confirmed. The club went on to claim that they would only deal with the FAB even though the FAB had not been formed. Indeed, the ISC confirmed that they had been in negotiations with the club over FAB terms of reference for 11 months. Unless and until the FAB had been agreed and formed, the ISC will continue to negotiate terms with the club. The ISC remained united and focused at this very challenging time for proper fan engagement.
Report was noted.
There being no further business Chair closed the meeting at 8.10pm thanking all for attending.



