Annual Report 2024

Hammers United Annual Report

ANNUAL REPORT
I start my report with the same words as last year:

“I remember addressing the 130 West Ham supporters who came to our first Hammers United meeting at the Plaistow Club.”

“I shouted ‘failure is not an option’ and I continually reiterate that sentiment.In the months that have gone by since, we have not failed.”

“But neither have we succeeded, and we must redouble our efforts on behalf of our members and all West Ham supporters.”

Hammers United spends a great deal of time on ‘casework’ taking up supporters’ problems with the Club, dealing with issues such as ticketing, Club cash, relocations, mascots and Club bans.

It is fair to say that by and large the Club staff are very helpful and with their assistance we achieve a reasonable level of success on behalf of West Ham United supporters.

Our efforts addressing key issues have, regretfully, not been as successful and I will address that at the end of this report.

The minutes of our last AGM can be found here:
AGM Minutes 2023 >>

There have been six committee meetings since the last AGM. The minutes can be found here:
Meetings >>

Season Ticket Payment Deadline
We wrote to the Club asking that the season ticket payment deadline be extended:
Season Ticket Payment Deadline >>

The Club replied suggesting any supporters experiencing difficulties paying should make contact directly to discuss possible support. We were pleased to note that some members did contact the Club and short extensions were granted. We thank the Club for its consideration.

Club Cash
We raised concerns about the current Club Cash system:
Club Cash >>

This issue remains ongoing. The ISC emailed the Club on March 11th prior to the next season ticket announcement requesting the removal of the ‘use it or lose it’ deadline and also asking that supporters selling tickets on Ticket Exchange have the option of being refunded in actual cash.

It is our belief that this would encourage more fans to use the Ticket Exchange which would result in fewer empty seats in the stadium. We will be looking to the new FAB to pursue this matter.

Changes To Concession Tickets
We raised with the Club, both independently and through the ISC, the raising of the qualifying age for concession tickets to 66, pointing out that West Ham and Aston Villa are the only two clubs in the Premier League to do this. Unfortunately the Club refused to reconsider.

We then received complaints from members that the Club was charging full price to 65 year olds attending away matches.
Over 65 Tickets for Away Matches >>
This problem had now been resolved and members refunded. The Club has since proposed further changes which I cover towards the end of this report.

Jonjo’s Bricks
We helped raise awareness of Jonjo’s efforts in returning personalised bricks from the commemorative wall at Upton Park to their owners.
Jonjo’s Bricks >>

We can only say well done to Jonjo. A tremendous effort by a fellow Hammer reuniting the bricks with their owners and at the same time raising money for the Bobby Moore Fund for CRUK.

Issues with Season Ticket Cards
Season Ticket Card Issues at West Ham v Chelsea Match >>
Problems accessing the stadium continue to be reported to us and we need to keep pressing for improvements across the board in the Club’s ticketing operation.

Unveiling Of The Giant Crest From The Boleyn Ground

The Crest is Coming Home >>

I can only say again how proud Hammers United are to have played our part in achieving this permanent reminder of our beloved home ground. This generation will never forget and future generations will always know that the Boleyn Ground was our home from 1904 to 2016.

John Lyall Plaque
As part of Hammers United’s ongoing efforts to ensure our history and heritage are celebrated, we worked with the family of John Lyall and the staff of Ilford County High School, where John was a pupil, to install a plaque in honour of our great manager of the 1970s and 1980s.
John Lyall Plaque >>

The Hero of Alkmaar
Back in September it came to our attention that the fan who bravely stood between rioting AZ Alkmaar hooligans and the families of West Ham players had suffered a stroke and that a Just Giving page had been set up to raise funds for his ongoing recovery and to help his family.

We reached out to our members and the wider West Ham fan base to raise awareness of the appeal for “one of our own”.

Hero of Alkmaar Support Update >>

The man continues to make progress but there is still a long, hard road ahead and we wish him and his family all the best.

Coach Travel To Liverpool
Liverpool Away Travel >>. We were not afforded the courtesy of a reply from the Club.

Accessibility Bus Issues
Accessibility Bus Issues >>. Again a very disappointing response from the Club.

Lasting and fitting tribute to John Lyall

Hammers United has been working with the Lyall family towards achieving a fitting and lasting tribute to John Lyall. We hope to be in a position to share more information with you soon.

Hammers United Survey
The new Hammers United survey is almost ready for release and this will provide us with a firm mandate from the fanbase on the issues we need to raise on behalf of West Ham fans.

Many thanks to Gareth at the FSA for his help putting this together.

Hammers United Travel Group Facebook Page
A number of our members suggested that we set up a dedicated Facebook page for our travelling fans and we are pleased to note that many of our members have found helpful information on traveling to matches both in England and Europe.
Hammers United Travel Group >>

Football Supporters Europe
We will continue to strengthen our good working relationship with FSE and look forward to assisting West Ham supporters when the Club plays in European competitions or friendly matches on the continent.

We met FSE following the Leverkusen away match to express our concerns at crushing/poor stewarding. FSE will be reporting to UEFA accordingly, hopefully leading to steps being taken to ensure a safer and positive experience going forward.

Football Supporters Association
We continue to work with the FSA and they have been very supportive in achieving the best possible terms for the imminent Fan Advisory Board.

They are now actively coordinating Premier League fan groups in a concerted campaign against price rises.

Hammers United with the support of our members intends to play a leading part.

Stewarding At London Stadium
Having reviewed the situation with our advisors and the FSA we made some small amendments and sent out the following up to date advice.
Stewarding at the London Stadium >>

Europa League Ticket Prices
The general consensus from our members was that the prices seemed on the high side leading us to seek more detailed feedback.  
Europa League Ticket Prices >>

There was a great deal of feedback and criticism, not so much with the prices (although in general they were higher than at Brighton and Liverpool) but that tickets had been put on sale before our opposition or KO time were known, along with the perceived ‘threat’ of price increases after the draw was made.

This was seen by fans as nothing less than a heavy handed sales technique employed by the Club.

The Hammers United rep on the ISC tried to raise the issue through the ISC but wasn’t even given the courtesy of a reply from the then Chair. Hopefully under the new leadership the ISC/FAB will do better next time.

New Fan Advisory Board
Hammers United, and in particular Andy Payne, have spent many hundreds of hours working towards improving the ISC and achieving the best possible terms for the new Fan Advisory Board.

We posted an interim update here:
West Ham United Fan Advisory Board Update >>

Andy then updated as follows:
New Fan Advisory Board >>

Season Ticket Price rises and proposed changes to concessions

The Independent Supporters Committee wrote to the club on March 11th.
ISC Statement on Season Ticket Prices and Proposed Changes to Concessions >>

Hammers United recognises that the Club’s latest ticketing strategy affects all supporters in a variety of different ways, none of which are positive, but there is one group of fans for whom the changes to concession tickets are especially hard hitting: Families and friends.

As is the natural order of things, there comes a time when our oldest and most loyal supporters are no longer able to attend matches. We cannot think of a time when it was anything other than the norm that their place would be taken by younger members of their family and friends, children and grandchildren, and thus new generations would continue the tradition of supporting West Ham.

That’s the natural progression. The way it has always been and always should be. However, the Club has taken a wrecking ball to this tradition.

From now on, families and friends in bands 1-4 who would like to transfer a season ticket to a new, young supporter (who would normally be offered a concession rate) will no longer be able to do this. Instead, the new concession rate season ticket would only be available in bands 5 and 6 which will see the disintegration of families’ and friends’ groups supporting West Ham together.

There is no doubt some new fans will not take up a season ticket and West Ham United will potentially lose a new generation of supporters.

It should be noted that before announcing its decision to press ahead with these changes, the Club did not consult the ISC, which represents many thousands of West Ham fans.

There are plenty of progressive ideas and solutions which could have been discussed and we are sure that a fair and equitable compromise could have been reached.

Instead, the Club chose to ignore its responsibility to consult and engage meaningfully with the ISC.

By “sheer coincidence” it transpires that most Premier League clubs are heading down the same route of inflation busting price increases and the removal of concessions from higher priced seat bands. Hammers United became aware of this worrying trend having attended an FSA meeting of Premier League fans groups.

Among fans up and down the land there is a clear appetite for co-ordinated and sustained protests against the actions being taken by Premier League clubs and Hammers United will play its part.

Summary
There is a recurring theme throughout this report – the terms of the ISC Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) – an agreement to which the Club signed up – clearly states “The purpose of the West Ham United Independent Supporters’ Committee (ISC) is to strengthen the relationship between West Ham United FC, West Ham United supporters and supporters’ groups, and to ensure the Club actively consults with supporters and takes their views into account at all levels of decision making.”

We note the following post on the KUMB fans forum:

My personal experience of dealing with the football Club through WHUISA has been that no ground can be ceded, nothing can be seen as being given to the fans as a “victory” and that engagement is seen by the football Club as a knife fight to the death on a sinking ship that is on fire.

The type of issues raised would range from pointing out incorrectly placed stones outside Turnstile J to questioning the price of food and drink and everything in between.

No matter too big or too small was seen as a full-frontal assault on the football Club and it had to be met with the firmest of response from those representing West Ham United.

This wasn’t The Battle of Helm’s Deep with the hordes storming the castle walls, this was West Ham fans trying to get a better deal for everyone else or a successful resolution of an individual’s personal issue.

The Club clearly has not honoured its obligations to date. For example, and one of many, the ISC terms clearly state that the agenda includes the Club’s ticket pricing. There was no consultation on season ticket prices!

Instead, and in typical fashion, the Club called the ISC to a meeting at very short notice to inform it of the prices a day or so before they were released.

The MOU also states “The Supporters’ Committee may table matters relating to Club decisions, challenging them where necessary.”

Frankly the ISC has been let down by weak leadership and has not helped itself. Indeed Hammers United moved at the ISC meeting of November 2022 “That Hammers United believes that the ISC should urgently consider whether or not the Club is adhering to its obligations with regard to consulting.”

The ISC Chair resigned in early January in 2024, following the Vice Chair who had resigned in late 2023. The ISC subsequently agreed to appoint Andy Payne (Hammers United) as interim Chair to lead and oversee negotiations on the new Fan Advisory Board.

I am proud to report that Andy has done a great job so far and that the ISC is now more transparent, accountable, democratic and united and is working together to achieve the best possible outcomes for West Ham United fans.

Huge credit to Andy and well done the rest of the ISC team. They have worked tirelessly towards achieving the best possible terms for the new FAB.

This new FAB should be in place by the end of the season and the Club has recently appointed a new Supporters Liaison Officer, Cat Smith. We are hoping for a re-set in the Club/fan relationship and look forward to the Club engaging meaningfully with all the fan groups.

I am confident that under Andy’s leadership we have, at long last, a fans’ committee that will hold the Club to account when necessary and do its best on behalf of the fanbase day in and day out.

We note and welcome the imminent introduction of an Independent Government regulator on football which will be monitoring progress of fan engagement.

There has been no lack of sustained hard work, plenty of frustration, some failure, some success and much ongoing. That’s the job and we have to ensure we do it to the best of our ability 24/7 on behalf of fans.

But we are now at a critical point. It is time for fans to make a stand and say ‘enough is enough’. Not just West Ham fans but all Premier League and Football League Club fans in unison.

There is so much that is wrong. Not just season ticket prices and concessions but fixture changes, kick off times, VAR and poor officiating, the list goes on and on. Some of these issues are within the gift of West Ham United Football Club to fix and we must ensure we hold them to account.

The game is getting away from all of us, and unless we drag it back we will lose it.

Hammers United must play its part. We will do our very best and we will look to our members for their support and to hold us accountable for our actions and the results we get.

FANS COUNT