Minutes of Hammers United Committee meeting (on zoom) held on Wednesday September 6th 2023.
Present:
P Colborne(Chair)
A Byrne (Joint Secretary)
G Barnard, I Pinamonti-Hyde, A Payne, D Procter, L Rogers
Chair opened the meeting at 5.15 pm sharp. He apologised for early start, recognising this had impacted attendance, but both he and Andy Payne had to work round other commitments.
Apologies:
Received from A Baker, S Cross, R Moran, S Patel, T Twohig.
Independent Supporters Committee
1 Old School Hammers.
A Payne reported that there was no procedure in place for a new group to be adopted onto the ISC. He had asked ISC Chair to write to OSH giving progress report.-Noted.
2 Minutes of ISC/Club meeting held on July 18th 2023.
The club had made several amendments to the minutes prepared by the ISC.
A Payne had now drafted a replacement minute and forwarded to the ISC for endorsement and forwarding to the club.
3 Minutes of ISC meeting held on 8th August 2023.
Chair had omitted debate on club cash. Andy Payne had specifically requested this be minuted. These minutes remain unpublished.
A Payne reported that ISC Chair would be contacting him to arrange a meeting to discuss the minutes outstanding.
4 Vote on Hammers United motion that the ISC/FAB be independent of the club.
‘That the ISC/FAB is to be independent of West Ham United Football Club and accordingly will produce and adopt a written constitution to ensure that it is democratic, accountable, transparent and independent.’
This had been seconded by Supporters Club rep on ISC with the ISC agreeing to take back to their respective committees for mandate and decision to be made at next ISC meeting.
Andy Payne reported that the vote was taken at the meeting of September 5th and our motion was defeated by 7 votes to 2.
The Bondholders rep had then moved
‘The Fan Advisory Board (FAB) will replace the Independent Supporters Committee (ISC). The FAB Supporters Representatives will be independent of West Ham United Football Club and this overarching principle is to be enshrined in the FAB Memorandum of Understanding.’
West Ham United Supporters Trust had seconded, adding an addendum ’and will inform further negotiations regarding the details of the MOU.’
A Payne reported concerns raised that ISC members should be afforded time to consider before voting, bearing in mind that a four week delay had been agreed before voting on the Hammers United motion. Nevertheless a vote was taken with the (Bondholders) motion carried 7 votes to 2.
Chair pointed out that this did not cover off the FAB being independent of the club. It did not specifically state the FAB must be independent of the club.
This led to full and frank debate round the table with members expressing surprise and disappointment. The consensus was that the ISC were giving up their independence without presenting their case and challenging the club, and that this could have serious consequences for fan engagement and the West Ham fanbase.
The following motion was then moved by G Barnard
‘That Hammers United cannot and will not betray the West Ham United fanbase and thus will only be part of an FAB where fans and independents decide on the members. The Club cannot choose who represents fans on the FAB.’
‘To this end the Chair and Joint Secretaries will seek a meeting with the FSA to discuss the proposed FAB and report back to this committee at a special meeting to be convened as soon as possible. The sole agenda item being how best Hammers United continue to serve the West Ham United fanbase.’
This was seconded by I Pinamonti-Hyde and carried unanimously.
A Payne then concluded his report by reporting ISC decision that any proposed FAB Memorandum of Understanding must be agreed by ALL ISC members.
At this point Chair thanked A Payne for his considerable efforts on behalf of our members under difficult circumstances.
There being no further business Chair closed the meeting at 6.00pm thanking all for attending.



