Hammers United Annual General Meeting Minutes 2023

Hammers United Annual General Meeting

Minutes of the (virtual by Zoom) Hammers United Annual General Meeting held on Tuesday May 23rd 2023.
Present
P Colborne (Chair)
A Byrne (Joint Secretary)

Committee members
G Bernard, A Payne, D Procter, L Rogers

Members
M Adie, P Anderson, A Baker,L Baker, S Banham, J Barnes, S Battram, S Byrne, S Cross, J Elliott, M Field, T Fischer, G Hobbs, D Houghton,M Johal, P Kersaw, A McConnell, C Miles, I Pinamonti-Hyde, P Prideaux, M Telling, ,J Tucker, H Webb, D Whyman,K Yellappa.

The Chair called the meeting to order at 6.30pm thanking all for attending. He proposed that the meeting should be recorded and there were no objections.

Apologies
Received from R Blane, J Farley, D Holder,R Keiff,G Marling, S Patel, K Perryman, T Twohig.

Annual Report
Chair drew attention to the Annual Report, already circulated. Report approved.

Joint Secretaries Report
Chair drew attention to Joint Secretaries report, already circulated. Report approved.

Treasurers Report
Chair drew attention to Treasurers report, already circulated. Report approved.

Election of Hammers United Committee
Chair confirmed that 12 positions were available. He then reminded the meeting that 11 nominations had been received and formally seconded and election addresses circulated.

Chair read out the names of nominees as follows:-
A Baker, moved P Colborne, seconded A Payne.
G Barnard, moved T Twohig, seconded L Rogers.
A Byrne, moved a McConnell, seconded L Rogers.
P Colborne, moved T Colborne, seconded A Payne.
S Cross, moved P Colborne, seconded L Rogers.
A Payne, moved P Colborne, seconded A McConnell.
S Patel, moved J Levin, seconded A Byrne.
I Pinamonti-Hyde, moved a Byrne, seconded P Colborne.
D Procter, moved P Colborne, seconded A Byrne.
L Rogers, moved S Allingham, seconded P Colborne.
T Twohig, moved G Bernard, seconded A Byrne.

Each were ratified individually by an affirmative vote.

Election of Chair
Chair asked for nominations leading to L Rogers nominating P Colborne. Nomination was seconded by A Payne.There being no further nominations P Colborne was re-elected.

Election of Joint Secretaries
Chair called for nominations leading to nominations as follows:
P Colborne nominated A Byrne. Nomination was seconded by S Cross.
A Byrne nominated S Cross. Nomination was seconded by a A McConnell.
There being no further nominations A Byrne was re-elected and S Cross elected.

Election of Representative on Independent Supporters Committee
Chair called for nominations, drawing attention to A Payne’s sterling work to date on this committee and proposing he be re-elected, nominating accordingly. Nomination was seconded by A McConnell. There being no further nominations A Payne was re-elected.

The Way Forward
(a) Fan Engagement – New Fan Advisory Board
A Payne gave full report. He hoped the Fan Advisory Board would see meaningful engagement from the club leading to genuine improvements for all West Ham fans. He felt that the ISC was in a good negotiating position to achieve an effective and viable new constraint with a sound MOU & Standing Orders. Hammers United would do everything in its power to make it work.

(b) Campaigns
Chair stressed we must prioritise the issues most important to our members as highlighted by complaints received.

Look and Feel of London Stadium – Sellers on the Approaches to the London Stadium
These had been identified by supporters as top priorities in Hammers United’s comprehensive survey. Chair reminded the meeting that Hammers United had first raised the issues of sellers at a structured dialogue meeting with the club on March 24 2021.

The club then asked to meet Hammers United both as a follow up and to discuss our vision, and reaffirmed their commitment to work with both Hammers United and the ISC on these two priorities identified by our survey.

We note that two years on there has been no real progress. The club has promised thee new sellers pitches. Chair pointed out that three pitches hardly enhanced the ‘feel’ of the London Stadium. The issue here was not to provide extra opportunities to buy merchandise but to enhance the atmosphere and help supporters feel like they were attending a football match.

Away Fans in Home Sections of London Stadium
Chair reminded the meeting that Hammers United had first raised this with the club on 23/9/19 which had led to extensive correspondence with the club. Again, arguably no progress made so far. There were huge numbers of Leeds fans in home sections only two days ago, three and a half years on from us expressing our concerns with the club.

Stewarding
Chair reported ongoing complaints received from our members. There were still huge problems with stewarding at London Stadium and arguably little or no progress had been made since London Stadium opened. A Payne reported that the ISC had carried out some work on what good stewarding should look like and Hammers United had worked on this. No feedback yet from the Club.

Catering at the London Stadium
Chair reminded the meeting that Hammers United had written to Delaware North on 10/8 2022 requesting they address prices with the utmost urgency ,drawing attention to both their moral and contractual obligations. We had forwarded to the Club on the same day.

The ISC and fan groups including Hammers United had mounted campaign to boycott food and drink in the London Stadium. Prices remain too high and as far as we know the club have still not made a legal challenge to Dellaware North although they had indicated that was their intention. Chair would be recommending to our committee that we revisit and step up this campaign.

The Wall
Chair reminded the meeting that we had first written to the club on 12/8/2022, asking why it was introduced, whose decision was it to introduce and why was there no consultation with the ISC?
A Payne then reported that the Newham Safety Advisory Group’s position was that the wall would be a permanent feature. He went on to point out that temporary netting had been installed between the home and away fans for the Alkmaar match but was unclear as to what the outcome of that experiment would be. Hammers United and the ISC would continue campaigning towards the walls removal.

Chair then pointed out obvious lack of progress in these campaigns despite the best efforts of Hammers United and the ISC.

We all hoped the New Fan Advisory Board would see more meaningful engagement from the Club and progress could be made on behalf of West Ham United fans. Hammers United would make every effort to support this. Chair would be recommending to our new committee that they monitor progress closely and that if the new Fan Advisory Board proves to be no more than a box ticking exercise then we should ballot our members on whether or not we should retain membership.

D Houghton asked if there was legal recourse we could explore should the club not engage meaningfully. A Payne confirmed that any concerns would have be taken up through the FSA unless and until the Government White Paper passed into law, which was at least two years away.

Safe Standing
A Payne gave an update. His understanding was that safe standing must be introduced for the 2024/25 season. Hammers United would input towards the ISC forwarding proposals to the club. As of now, there are no plans from the Club for safe standing.

Customer Service/Ticketing
Chair pointed out that clearly both the customer service and ticketing operations at the Club left much to be desired. Andy Byrne supported, the bar was certainly low but we had to work towards improvement and particularly for more transparency. A breakdown from the club of away ticket distribution would be a start.

Fan Behaviour
Chair raised concerns at lack of respect shown by some fans to others. This was supported by A Baker who felt that many problems were caused by drugs. P Anderson felt this might be the time to look at possibilities of creating a family section at London Stadium.

Help for Our Away Support
Chair reminded the meeting that Hammers United and written to the club in January 2020 asking that they lay on free coach travel. The Club subsequently organised free travel to Liverpool, Manchester United and Newcastle. This was of course against a background of Hammers United organising a large scale protest. And we note a similar request was recently ignored.

Chair would be recommending that our committee explore all avenues into how the Club might help our loyal away support. Once a clear course of action is agreed our committee could liaise with the away supporters rep on the ISC towards a formal approach being made to the Club.

Heritage
The Chair reminded the meeting of our success rescuing the giant crest from the Boleyn ground and reported that we are working with another fans group on a different initiative which at present must remain confidential.

Access to Stadium
Chair reminded the meeting that the same problems exist. We have had specific complaints from members and will be meeting them to discuss. When we have drawn up an action plan we will liaise with the Disabled Supporters Board and the Old School Hammers.

Meeting noted that Leeds coaches had dropped next to the stadium.

Late Frankie Sait
Chair reported we have been approached by Frank’s friends and family hoping that the club could erect a permanent memorial. Steve Cross supported and gave background information.

Frankie was a young West Ham fan who went off to see his team play and never came home. Both would recommend our committee take this up with the Club.

Social Events
Chair reminded meeting of our successful boat trip .He and the Joint secretaries had come up with ideas for Hammers United social events in the close season which they would run past the committee.

Season Ticket prices
A Payne gave an update. Hammers United had reacted to our members disappointment by raising petition. West Ham United Supporters Club and Bondholders had canvassed respective memberships confirming their members disappointment and the ISC had subsequently challenged the Club. As yet the club had not responded.

At this point Chair asked the meeting if there were any questions re proposed campaigns, if anyone had other suggestions of work we could undertake to benefit the fanbase, or if anyone would like to raise anything under any other business.

Other Business
C Miles expressed concerns at implications of installing safe standing at London Stadium drawing attention to the shallow rake. He felt that safe standing might be counter productive.S Cross reminded the meeting of discussions Hammers United  have previuosly had with architects re configuration of the stadium.

D Houghton sought progress report on possible GDPR breach following the supply of tickets for Larnaca away match. Chair reported that there had been no further response from the club and that we believed they had still neither given a full explanation as to what went wrong or provided adequate reassurance that steps had been taken to prevent a repeat. Chair understood that several members had now forwarded complaints to the Information Commissioner’s Office.

The Chair then concluded by reporting that he would convene a meeting of the newly elected committee ASAP so we could start work towards hopefully achieving on behalf of West Ham United fans. He then closed the meeting at 7.45 pm thanking all for attending.