Committee Meeting Minutes September 29th 2022

Meeting Minutes

Minutes of Hammers United Committee Meeting held on Thursday 29th September 2022.

Present

P Colborne(Chairman)

A.Byrne,A McConnell(Joint Secretaries)

G Barnard,D Holder,S Patel,A Payne,D Procter,L Rogers,V Ryan,T Twohig,

Apologies.

Received from R Blane.

The Chairman called the meeting to order at 6.00 pm sharp.

There would be one item on the Agenda,namely the West Ham United Independent supporters Committee.

Background.

The Chair gave background.The Club was not adhering to the MOU as they were not ‘positively engaging with the ISC at all times’.The ISC were not adhering to the MOU by ‘ ensuring the club listens to supporters & takes their views into account at all levels of decision making.’

The ISC was not acting as a democratic organisation.Hammers United had evidenced and  complained  to the FSA.Other member groups had complained about Hammers United.The FSA had investigated but still not forwarded report.

Club’s new communication process.

Chair gave a full report.Hammers United is forwarding issues to the club from members experiencing difficulties obtaining Season Ticket cards.-This had been agreed with Ticket office manager.The club has now emailed us stating that the club no longer wish to deal with Hammers United advising we refer our members direct to the Ticket Office.We should adhere to the new communications process drawn up by the club.

This would put us in a position where there would be no way of effectively representing our members direct with the club.

Hammers United had challenged the club pointing out that this process had not been discussed and debated by the ISC let alone agreed.The club had copied the ISC Interim Chair and FSA into the correspondence but  they had not challenged the club.

The club had since written to Hammers United in an attempt to clarify that the new communication process was not a replacement for structured dialogue There was no mention of the new CP being just a  proposal rather than an agreement nor was there any acknowledgement that the Club’s communication channels for supporters were so poor that many of them come to Hammers United seeking help.

Chair then read out response from him and the Joint secretaries.
“We would have welcomed the opportunity to discuss the communication proposal as an ISC, before being informed by the club that it was an agreement and asked by the club to adhere to it.
We will discuss the situation as a committee and we will seek the support of the ISC on this matter.
Our committee discussions will note that our recent request for a structured dialogue meeting, over a matter where the ISC wanted to take no further action, was not granted. They will also note that individuals who contact us, looking for assistance with individual enquiries, do so as they have failed to get a response or a satisfactory outcome from the club channels open to them.”

LR moved the full committee endorse reply.Seconded AM,carried unanimously.

 

The Chair then invited A Byrne to outline club’s proposal for consideration by the committee and mandate given to our ISC rep.

This led to full and frank debate and and resolutions carried as follows:-

1.That  Hammers United strongly oppose the clubs proposal.It is an attempt to undermine the MOU and to dictate the terms by which the ISC operate.It would seriously compromise our ability to represent our members .Moved AP,seconded TT,carried unanimously.

2.That Hammers United seek the support of other ISC supporter groups rejecting club proposal.Moved LR.seconded SP,carried unanimously.

3.That Hammers United seek the support of the FSA rejecting this proposal.Moved GB.,seconded DH,carried unanimously.

The Chair and Joint Secretaries would contact the ISC and FSA accordingly.

The Chair then recommended  that the Committee meet again next week to discuss responses and the way forward.

LR moved endorsement,seconded AB,carried unanimously.

Chair then closed the meeting at 6.50 pm thanking all for attending.