A letter to HU

When I look back on Sunday 18 April 2021, I think it would be fair to say the announcement made that day sent ripples across the football community. The full picture around football ownership and fans connection to their clubs was brought into focus.

That day, proposals for a European Super League were a blunt and brazen admission of the regard in which many supporters are held by the owners of their football clubs. These supporters now even have a name: ‘Legacy Fans’.

In short, these legacy fans were considered to be of no use to clubs at the top end of our game. They do not generate enough revenue. Furthermore, the experience they cherish and wish to see maintained at their football club, causes a nuisance when trying to convert your business and prepare it for ‘Future Fans’.

However, a football club is not just a business.

And supporters are not just customers.

I read with interest the statement from our own vice-chairman following the announcement on April 18. This statement appeared to distance our club from the views held by owners of the ‘big six’. It appeared to position us a club where owners have a real understanding of what it means to be a legacy fan and as a club where owners have a deep desire to protect the experience for these fans.

The announcement from the self-proclaimed ‘big six’ on Sunday 18 April was followed by a series of further announcements and apologies from other owners. The Super League fell-apart before that weeks football fixtures could be completed. I believe fan pressure played its part in a notable victory for the real owners of our game and our football clubs.

As the dust settles, questions are being asked about the significance of Sunday April 18 2021 and whether this could be a pivotal moment in mapping out the future of football. The unity from managers, players, pundits and fans alike in condemning the intentions of the owners involved was refreshing.

However, many supporters up and down the country will have simply been witnessing outrage over a topic that was already all too familiar.

We all want reform and if this is the springboard to achieve it, then that is undoubtedly positive. Although supporters of Blackpool, Charlton, Bolton, Bury, Macclesfield, Newcastle and many, many more could be forgiven for feeling a little frustrated that the turning point could only occur once so many of those feeding from the trough came under threat.

Indeed supporters of West Ham United, like myself, may have been frustrated that the issue only appeared to gain widespread positive coverage once the ‘big six’ were the ones highlighting it.

And what of the statement released by our club?

What of their position?

When placed side by side with previous comments and actions it absolutely stank of hypocrisy. The statement came from same people who had misled our fanbase and destroyed so much of what we loved at West Ham, all in search of a pound note. I think the arrogance of these people simply knows no bounds.

‘as a club that was founded by working-class shipbuilders over 125 years ago, is deeply rooted in its own community and is acutely aware of the traditions of English football’

From the people that spoke of ‘history beginning’ at the London Stadium in 2016. The people who sold off much of our heritage, the people who only recently left it for the fans to club together and buy an important part of our heritage (the Bobby Moore stand crest) and the people who promised a club museum which is still nowhere to be seen. I believe we don’t even have a premises for our supporters club.

‘Thames Ironworks FC was formed in June 1895 by Arnold Hills, a man who believed his local community should have its own football team. Well over a century later West Ham United, owned by two supporters, remains at the heart of our community, true to its working-class values.’ 

This from the same people who failed to support the local businesses destroyed by the move to Stratford. The same people that have done their best to rebrand our club, totally disregarding its working-class roots. What would Arnold Hills think now? How disappointed he would be to see the disgraceful displacement of thousands of time–served fans of the club, with associations that go back generations, many to his shipyards. They have paid the ultimate price for the scandalous manner in which the transition from our spiritual home, the Boleyn Ground in Upton Park, a few miles across the borough to the Olympic Park in Stratford, has been handled.

‘the foundations of our club and our sport are based on the integrity of competition and the loyal support of our fans who have grown up as members of the claret and blue army and followed us over land and sea.’

The same supporters that, in their thousands, have walked away from our great club. Five relegations could not dampen their spirit in the past, but GSB have driven them away. Fans that, in many cases, followed the club for decades as did their parents before them.

Our supporters have been there throughout our 125-year journey, for our FA Cup and European Cup Winners’ Cup wins, our promotions and many other memorable moments. I believe they have been let down so badly by the West Ham board that many no longer want to be part of the journey. Our vice-chairman once said she values the support of the casual fan on the other side of the world as much as one who has followed our team up and down the country over the years.

‘these proposals go totally against the ethos and values – the West Ham way – that have inspired us to those unforgettable successes and will shape the next generation of hammers, on and off the pitch.’

What is the West Ham way? Charging astronomical sums for matchday mascot packages perhaps? Or charging £10 to join a season ticket waiting list that is the ‘only way’ of securing a ticket, then allowing people to buy multiple tickets, in effect jumping the queue? Or maybe just match-day stewards who do not understand our club or our supporters?

‘West Ham United will continue to do everything possible standing together with its supporters, government, governing bodies and the wider football community to resist this attack on football in the best interests of our club and of the game we all love.’

I don’t remember the current owners of West Ham standing together with their supporters? West Ham played at the Emirates a few years ago, in a night match, and got hammered. That evening, in the build up to what was a massive game for us, our vice-chair tweeted praising the cheeseboard and cakes. She has no idea of what ‘standing together with the supporters’ means. Where was the message of support for our team?

https://www.90min.com/posts/4830030-self-obsessed-parasite-karren-brady-angers-west-ham-fans-after-tweeting-about-arsenal-s-desserts

‘we believe we have a social responsibility to do so and will continue to keep staff and supporters fully updated.’

I’d like to revisit the statement reminding us that ‘West Ham is owned by two supporters’. Mr Gold is a West Ham supporter and Mr Sullivan may now claim to be (he previously had allegiance to Cardiff City). Are they so different from the owners of the ‘big six’ who have rightly been heavily criticised for apparently putting profit before all else?

So far, I believe Gold and Sullivan have charged the club around £19 million in interest on loans. Initially, they charged between 6% and 7% interest, but when this became public knowledge there was outcry from supporters and they subsequently reduced the rate to 4.5%. Fellow board member Tripp Smith has lent West Ham £9.5 million, but does not charge interest.

When looking at other Premier League clubs, I see that Roman Abramovich charges Chelsea no interest on loans. Tony Bloom has lent Brighton over £300 million and charges no interest. Mike Ashley, hated by Newcastle fans, has lent Newcastle around £130 million interest free. Everton’s owners have lent them over £200 million and Liverpool’s owners around £100 million; both at a lower rate than that charged by Gold and Sullivan.

Indeed, interest paid on all the loans from all the Premier League owners put together in the last five years, apparently falls far short of interest earned by Mr Gold and Mr Sullivan. In the Sunday Times rich list, Mr Gold is valued at £450 million and Mr Sullivan at £1.15 billion. Do they really need to charge West Ham such high interest rates?

As fans we invest our hearts and souls in West Ham. From our first trip to the Boleyn Ground until the day we die. We expect no financial return from that investment. If the club owners are genuine West Ham fans, as they claim to be, then surely there is no need for them to benefit financially from the sums they have lent.

And what of our vice-chairman?

I know she writes her column for The Sun, which has upset fans on many occasions. When West Ham played Stoke at home in a relegation 6 pointer, our  vice-chair tweeted plugging her new TV show airing at the same time!

lady karren brady on twitter

“my new show give it a year starts on itv tonight 8pm i meet a series of aspiring entrepreneurs from all different walks of life with a wide variety of ideas as they launch their business then return a year later to see if they are successful & you’ll see the results immediately https://t.co/pha2rivwqd”

Twitter.com

I believe supporters are not fooled by the spin. Our owners are in it for the money. It is not about history and heritage and ‘legacy fans’.

The shambles of the botched stadium migration; misleading a loyal fanbase, and the rebranding of the club without proper consultation with the fans have hurt our supporters.

Perhaps now the football pendulum is swinging towards the fans. A fan led review into football governance is underway and the announcement on April 18 definitely sparked something.

Perhaps fan-power really can make a difference? Supporters across the game now need to join the campaign for the match-going fan to be put first.

Our team has done brilliantly this season. I, like many others, fully support our manager, his staff and our players.

I believe we must always do our utmost to help create a passionate and intimidating atmosphere. We must do all we can to help our team.

At the same time, we must not forget what we are fighting for because of our team’s performances. There are bigger issues. Our success is in spite of, not due to, the board.

Whilst supporting our team I think we can all still join the campaign for new ownership and the push for reform that will see ‘legacy fans’ truly represented at our clubs.

I believe West Ham can be United.

Fans can make a difference.

I have every faith in Hammers United to continue to lead West Ham supporters towards our ultimate goal.